MLB Draft Grades: Top Teams' Top Picks Over the Last Decade
The MLB draft is a crucial part of building a successful baseball team, and the top picks can make or break a franchise's future. Over the last decade, some teams have excelled in their draft choices, while others have struggled to find the right talent. This article takes a deep dive into the top picks of each team from 2016 to 2025, analyzing their average draft position, total WAR produced, and notable achievements.
A+ - Seattle Mariners
The Mariners have been a consistent force in the MLB, and their draft strategy has been a key factor in their success. With an average draft position of 14.7, they have produced eight major leaguers with a total WAR of 30.7. Their top picks have included Logan Gilbert, George Kirby, and Emerson Hancock, forming a strong rotation. Additionally, they have snagged high schoolers Cole Young and Colt Emerson, showcasing their ability to identify talent early on.
A - Detroit Tigers
The Tigers have had a strong showing in the draft, with an average draft position of 8.6. They have produced seven major leaguers with a total WAR of 24.3. Notable picks include Riley Greene, Casey Mize, and Spencer Torkelson, who have become key contributors. The Tigers' consistent success in the draft has helped them build a competitive team.
A - San Diego Padres
The Padres have taken a high-risk, high-reward approach to the draft, focusing on high-ceiling but volatile high schoolers. Their average draft position of 14.9 has produced six major leaguers with a total WAR of 37. Notable picks include MacKenzie Gore and CJ Abrams, who have become All-Stars. However, the Padres have also traded many of their top picks, showcasing their willingness to take risks.
A- - Milwaukee Brewers
The Brewers have found success with their mid-market picks, with an average draft position of 18. They have produced six major leaguers with a total WAR of 27.3. Notable picks include Brice Turang and Garrett Mitchell, who have become key contributors. The Brewers' strategy of focusing on college bats has paid off, with Andrew Fischer knocking on the door for a starting role.
B+ - Chicago Cubs
The Cubs have a strong scouting system, with an average draft position of 27. They have produced seven major leaguers with a total WAR of 30.6. Notable picks include Nico Hoerner, who has produced a significant amount of WAR. The Cubs' consistent success in the draft has helped them maintain a competitive team.
B - Chicago White Sox
The White Sox have had a strong showing in the draft, with an average draft position of 11.7. They have produced eight major leaguers with a total WAR of 27.2. Notable picks include Garrett Crochet, who has become a key contributor. The White Sox's draft strategy has helped them build a strong team.
C+ - Atlanta Braves
The Braves have had a mixed showing in the draft, with an average draft position of 20.5. They have produced six major leaguers with a total WAR of 16.2. Notable picks include Ian Anderson, who has pitched in crucial playoff games. The Braves' draft strategy has helped them build a competitive team, but they have struggled to find consistent success.
C - Cleveland Guardians
The Guardians have had a consistent showing in the draft, with an average draft position of 24.4. They have produced six major leaguers with a total WAR of 12.5. Notable picks include Gavin Williams and Chase DeLauter, who have become key contributors. The Guardians' draft strategy has helped them maintain a competitive team.
D - Miami Marlins
The Marlins have struggled in the draft, with an average draft position of 9.5. They have produced five major leaguers with a total WAR of 19.2. Notable picks include Max Meyer, who has become an All-Star rotation stalwart. The Marlins' draft strategy has been inconsistent, with a mix of high schoolers and proven college arms.
